Research programme

Comprehensive Theory of Peace

Bringing the common ground and its indicators together into a comprehensive theory of peace

What the programme does

The Comprehensive Theory of Peace programme brings together the work of the three programmes before it: the definitions of peace gathered by Concepts and Definitions of Peace, the common ground identified by Common Ground for Peace and the indicators developed by Peace Measurement and Indicators. From these it drafts a comprehensive theory of peace. It is offered as a starting point for discussion, to be examined, tested and corrected by others. The Peace in Law, Policy and Institutions programme then applies it.

What a theory of change is

Those who work for peace plan their work with a theory of change. The theory of peace is meant to serve them, by stating the goal. A theory of change explains how an organization expects its work to lead to the change it seeks. It sets out, step by step, how what is invested and done is expected to produce results. Governments, United Nations entities, funders and civil society organizations use theories of change to plan, fund and evaluate their work.

The chain of a theory of change

Each step is expected to lead to the next.

  1. InputsWhat is invested, such as funding, time and expertise
  2. ActivitiesWhat is done, such as mediation, training or research
  3. OutputsWhat is produced, such as agreements, reports or trained people
  4. OutcomesWhat changes as a result
  5. ImpactThe lasting change sought, which for peace work is peace itself

The last step names the goal. Every other step is chosen because it is expected to lead there.

Why the goal matters

A theory of change can only be as clear as its idea of the goal. In peace work, that goal is seldom defined. The Charter of the United Nations makes the maintenance of international peace and security the first purpose of the Organization, but international law has no generally accepted definition of peace.

As a result, those who work for peace often work towards different ends. As early as 1976, a review of the peace research field found researchers “studying different problems and pursuing divergent goals, all under the banner of ‘peace’” (Johnson 1976, quoted in Reagan 2023). The same holds in practice, from mediators and educators to funders, States, courts and United Nations bodies. A 2023–2024 synthesis review for the United Nations Peacebuilding Fund found that evaluations struggled to judge impact across the Fund’s portfolio without a portfolio-level theory of change.

When the concept of peace is fragmented

  • Each actor works towards their own idea of peace
  • Efforts pull apart and can cancel each other out
  • Commitments to peace are difficult to assess against a common standard
  • Those who use violence can claim the word peace

When the common ground is stated explicitly

  • The same actors work towards a shared goal
  • Efforts can reinforce one another
  • Shared standards carry more weight
  • Claims of peace can be tested

A statement of what definitions share

A review published in 2024 counted 61 concepts of peace in research published between 1969 and 2022. The Institute does not set out to add one more concept to compete with these. It looks for the common ground that the existing concepts share, and for a framework that underlies them and gives them a common language. Its 2026 article sets out that common ground as a single account of peace. The article shows how 12 of the 61 concepts fit within it, and the Institute is now checking the rest. The account will be revised in the light of what that work finds.

Peace and violence are meant to apply to everyone equally. The common ground that gives them their meaning must therefore hold for every person equally, whatever their language, culture, religion, gender, age, class or any other characteristic. How we work sets out the method this requires.

A starting point for discussion

Actors at every level, from faith leaders and local communities to intergovernmental bodies, have their own theories of change, each suited to their own work. The comprehensive theory of peace is offered as a proposal about the goal these actors may already share, drawn from what their own understandings of peace likely already have in common. It describes the goal. How to reach it is for each actor to decide.

If others find that the proposal holds, the work of many actors could add up. Results could be compared and measured against the same standard, and gaps and duplication would become easier to see. The aim is that efforts for peace reinforce one another.

The misuse of the word peace

Because peace is valued everywhere, the word has at times been invoked to justify armed conflict and repression.

In 1969 the peace researcher Takeshi Ishida warned of such “wars for peace”. This misuse works only while peace has no generally settled meaning.

A shared account of peace would allow such claims to be examined. A claim of peace can be checked against the conditions it produces for the people affected: does an action leave them more able, or less able, to determine their own lives?

Where the programme fits

The Institute’s five research programmes form one sequence. The first three together yield the theory of peace, and the fifth applies it.

  1. Concepts and Definitions of PeaceGathers how peace is defined and used in research, law, policy and practice. It aims to produce a full record of these definitions, on which the other programmes build.
  2. Common Ground for PeaceCompares those definitions to find what they have in common, including assumptions they make without stating them. It aims to state that common ground clearly, so others can engage with it.
  3. Peace Measurement and IndicatorsWorks out how peace can be observed and measured in practice: within a person, between people and between groups. It aims to produce indicators of peace that can be checked against data.
  4. Comprehensive Theory of PeaceBrings together the definitions, their common ground and its indicators. It aims to produce a comprehensive theory of peace, offered as a starting point for discussion.
  5. Peace in Law, Policy and InstitutionsApplies the theory of peace to law, policy and institutions. It aims to show how far they are in line with it, and how far they produce peace or violence.

Research overviewHow we work